« I love conflicts like this one... | Main | Trafficking in tsunami orphans? »

Cautious optimism on Social Security

It appears that the Bush administration will soon unveil a plan to allow workers to own a portion of their Social Security accounts. The details won't be in until next month, but it looks like they're considering allowing workers to contribute 4% of their FICA taxes to private accounts. At first glance, the 4% figure seems bolder than the expected 2% -- but then comes the fine print. The president's commission also recommended capping contributions at $1,000 a year. That means that while someone salaried at $25K can contribute the whole 4%, someone earning $50K will effectively be limited to 2%. I'm not sure why they would structure it this way, but my guess is to inject an element of progressivity into the plan in an effort to pre-empt the charge that privatization would unfairly benefit high income earners.

Who knows? But whatever the details, this is truly encouraging. I never thought I would see the day when privatization was actually seriously proposed by a sitting president. Granted, it will be an uphill battle. Bush may not succeed, but I do not doubt that he will try. Say what you will about him, but he is not afraid to cash in political capital to fight for something he believes in, and he has a largely friendly congress to work with. It's a bold move, and it may not yet be politically possible. But if it is, this president will do it.

TrackBack

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Cautious optimism on Social Security:

» More on Social Security private accounts from Carpe Bonum
Clearly, the debate hasn't been directly joined. How does the Left propose to compensate for the demographic problem? Isn't it better to get better returns through investment? Hopefully we will get some discussion on this. There is time. [Read More]

Comments

I don't understand, why is being allowed to invest a percentage of your FICA contribution encouraging? Stocks are volatile, and I for one prefer the Social Security plan to rest on steadier ground.

It just seems to me that a whole lot of people in this country aren't prepared for private investing, and a lot more will be lost than gained.

If you prefer the current system, then by all means, you shouldn't participate. But it's a bit unsporting to deny the option to those who would.

OK. Nice try.
What's unsporting and unsportsmanlike is the transparent, semi-clever attempt by the administration to shift the blame for social security's upcoming demise on the taxpayer. "What, me, I didn't screw up your benefits. Why, you made poor investment choices...."
Just kidding!
Any of my $$ that I can wrest from the gov's clutches and invest myself would be welcome.
Hi, Newel.

Post a comment